Issue 1 - April 2008                                                                                                                                                                                

    Contents / ThomasGM / Interntnl / Media / Psyched / Fashion / Art / Edit / Court Tips / Goss / Club / KidsZone / Win Stuff                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Page 9                 ►NEXT PAGE   

   

 

EDITORIAL

 

 Cliff Freeman

 

Editor for this Magazine, Development 

 Manager,

 Auckland

 Badminton

 

auckbad.co.nz

 

 

NZ Olympic Qualifying - Are Our Standards Too High ?

 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 

 


 


 


 


 

With Beijing looming it is a high pressure time for athletes looking to qualify the Olympics.  Over the last few months we have seen some interesting and close battles in some spots for places. 

 

With any qualification process there is a question of peaking not only for the trial process but for the Olympics itself - not an easy process - and for each sport this process is different depending on the events they have to qualify for and the timing of trials etc.  There is an 18 month window for sports to qualify.  Each sport has to balance the risk of naming athletes early to allow them to prepare vs announcing later to allow for changes in form. 

 

 Craig Cooper and 

 Renee Flavell - on the

 road to Beijing?

In NZ we set our qualification standards high and in badminton this could cause an interesting anomaly in 2008.  Currently the NZ mixed pair of Renee Flavell and Craig Cooper (pictured) are trying to qualify for the mixed doubles.  They are currently ranked 29 in the world.  To qualify under the NZOC criteria they must be in the top 16 in the World.  However International rules allow one pair from Oceania to qualify to make up one of the 16 pairs at the Olympics (similar to the Soccer World Cup). 

 

Therefore if Renee and Craig are not allowed to go it is likely that the Australian Mixed Pair will go to the Olympics taking that Oceania spot.  The Australian pair are ranked 58 in the world (29 places below the NZ pair).  What the Australians set as a standard of course is not in NZOC's control however the result could be that the top ranked Oceania pair do not attend.  So Is this fair and what are the alternatives?

 

Why Is NZ's Qualifying Different To That Of Australia In This Area? 

 

 

I asked Barry Maister NZ Olympic Committee (NZOC) Secretary General whether it was a question of funding that created the need for a higher standard.  However he said that funding is absolutely not an issue regarding qualification, far from it, but that it is purely a matter of setting a standard.      

 

He said that with any sport there is a trade off - set the standards too low and getting to the Olympics could be seen as being a bit too easy, downgrading the pride factor of going to the Olympics.  Set them too high and you risk talented young athletes missing out on experiences that could earn them valuable experience for the future. 

 

Barry pointed out that the NZOC retains the right to use some discretion in the selection process, and will always consider those who NSOs believe have good reason for consideration even if the NZOC standard is not met.

 

  

 

The NZOC are currently reviewing the issue of qualification standards for the Olympics.  Although there is a chance for consideration should athletes have to go through that uncertainty when they have made the international qualifying standard? What do you think about it and the standard NZ sets for Olympic Qualification? Are we setting the bar too high?

 

Email your thoughts to shuttle.exp@gmail.com - put "editorial" in the subject row - and your comments could end up on this page next issue.